Happy stories with loving relationships, but nary a saccharine note. Real, honest, children’s viewpoints. Young girls who, like Billy Miller (which won a Newbery Honor — did you see?!?! So thrilled about that) are good, and like being good, yet have not a snitch of prissy, goody-two-shoes about them.
That’s what you get in both of these warm, engaging books, which are so unalike in most other ways. Oh — there’s no mother in either of them. That’s another similarity. First up is…
Bo at Ballard Creek, by Kirkpatrick Hill, illustrated by LeUyen Pham published in 2013 by Henry Holt and Company
…and it’s the winner of the 2014 Scott O’Dell prize for best historical fiction. Read it, and you’ll see why.
It’s set in a tiny mining town in Alaska, 1930.
Two strapping, barrel-chested guys — Arvid and Jack — have been knocking around these parts since they stampeded up during the 1897 Klondike gold rush. One life-changing day, a spiteful gal named Millie up and hands her infant daughter to Arvid, tells him to deposit her in an orphanage, traipses onto a steamboat, and leaves without a backward glance.
But Arvid and Jack, who have hearts to fit their girth, take that baby girl in and raise her as their own. Bo, they call her, and not knowing the first thing about babies, they fall desperately in love with her in a twinkle.
Bo is about five years old as our story begins. She speaks Eskimo and English, makes fluffy, golden biscuits like nobody’s business, and feels utterly at home in this insular world of miners and Eskimos, good-time girls and sled-dog couriers. There are adventures and hard times, celebrations and daily chores. Always, there are Arvid and Jack — the anchors of her contented life.
Kirkpatrick Hill’s book reads a bit like a Little House story with its charming string of anecdotes. LeUyen Pham’s warm-as-toast illustrations even echo Garth Williams’ sense I think, and the layout of the ivory pages with their rough cut edges all strike the same note as those early Little House editions. Laura Ingalls was a spunky girl, and Bo is, too, but Bo’s honest gaze at life is more penetrating than Laura’s. Marvelous, matter-of-fact voice throughout the book, a host of colorful characters, and such a rich depiction of this world. I couldn’t put it down. Fabulous read-aloud for ages 6 and up. There’s a little sprinkling of spicy language from time to time courtesy of the miners, just FYI.
Then, coming from Sweden, a chapter book for girls from 6-10…
My Happy Life, by Rose Lagercrantz, illustrated by Eva Eriksson published in 2013 by Gecko Press
This one packs a lot of emotion into its sparsely-worded pages.
Dani is just old enough to start school, which brings quite a mix of excitement and trepidation. Her biggest worry is: what if I don’t make any friends? Understandable.
Happily, despite a lot of rowdy mayhem on the playground, Dani spots Ella and they quickly become best friends, stuck together like peanut butter and jam. One heartbreaking day, though, Ella moves away.
Dani is no stranger to grief, having lost her mother years ago. Now a bewildering new thorn of unhappiness deflates her, stings her. It takes tender understanding from her dad and others in her life, time, a couple of sparkle-eyed hamsters, some bad days and redeeming moments, before Dani is able to identify herself as happy again.
Sweet, poignant, insightful. Emotionally-honest without veering beyond the young narrator’s voice. And despite the bruises in Dani’s life — this story has a happy outlook and ending. Charmingly illustrated by Eva Eriksson, an award-winning, much loved Swedish illustrator. Her illustrations and a lot of white space really dominate the pages since these 20 teeny chapters have an unusually low word count. It’s pretty much a girl-book, that works for an early chapter book, a reluctant reader, or a read-aloud.
I’m really disappointed in your recommendation of “Bo at Ballard Creek”. My children and I have benefited greatly from the books you highlight and rarely a week goes by that we aren’t picking up something from the library you suggested. We sat down today to start reading about Bo and didn’t make it past the second chapter. Spicy language, yes and also repeated mentions of the good-time girls including Mean Millie who we learn is Bo’s mom. I kept trying to edit before I read aloud, but realized I would not be able to do that. Perhaps I am overly sensitive to the portrayal of birth moms who “up and leave” as an adoptive parent of two. The flippant manner that it was handled in the book was too much for me. Too many questions were left hanging in the air that my 5 and 8 year olds are not ready for!
I really do appreciate your website as a whole, but think that this was a poor choice!
Thanks, Kate, for your helpful comments. I hope that others trying to decide on this book will benefit from your perspective. I know I always appreciate reading different opinions on books before I wade into them. I’m sorry for your disappointment in this title.
This book does include some painful pieces of life — Bo’s abandonment, and later a small boy who is traumatized when he is suddenly orphaned — as well as some women whom we would not choose as role models for our girls. I thought the seeming flippancy regarding Millie was actually Arvid’s attempt to soften the really, really painful blow he knew Bo had been dealt; to not plant more rancour in her bereft heart. Bo’s sense of having lost her mother tracks through the story and I did not see it as a light thing at all. That pain is part of her identity, and I think it actually shapes her quite a bit. My sense was that this loss is a deep part of the story, and that the author was attempting to incorporate it, and let us see how these children were able to move on through the love of others. Your perspective as an adoptive mother is very helpful, so thanks again for that.
Like you, I wondered a bit about including the good time girls in the story, and that is why I specifically mentioned them in my review. But as I kept reading and wrestling with that, I ended up liking how human the author makes these women. You meet more of them further on in the story. As our family has worked closely with many people with very broken lives, addictions, previous felonies, and so on, my kids have learned that they are all complex people, with brokenness, yes, but with tenderness, too. This book seemed to treat these women as I would want to treat them myself and never really says much about what it is they do.
I can understand, though, how this would not suit every family, and as I say, I’m really glad to have your comments for others to reference.
[…] met Dani in an earlier book, My Happy Life, which I reviewed here. She’s a wispy-haired, elfin girl, about age 6 who lives with her dear father. Her mother has […]
[…] in this vibrant Swedish series about Dani. If you haven’t met her before, you really need to begin at the beginning as her wranglings with life as well as her relationships with her widower father, her best friend […]
[…] via the wonderful people at Gecko Press. You have to read the whole series in order. The first is My Happy Life, reviewed here. For those of you whose daughters have become fast friends with Dani and her BFF Ella, you will not […]
[…] six-book sequence covers about two years of young Dani’s life beginning with My Happy Life, reviewed here. Without giving away too much of the plot, this final episode sees Dani recover from a lengthy […]
Both of these sound excellent. Thanks!
I’m really disappointed in your recommendation of “Bo at Ballard Creek”. My children and I have benefited greatly from the books you highlight and rarely a week goes by that we aren’t picking up something from the library you suggested. We sat down today to start reading about Bo and didn’t make it past the second chapter. Spicy language, yes and also repeated mentions of the good-time girls including Mean Millie who we learn is Bo’s mom. I kept trying to edit before I read aloud, but realized I would not be able to do that. Perhaps I am overly sensitive to the portrayal of birth moms who “up and leave” as an adoptive parent of two. The flippant manner that it was handled in the book was too much for me. Too many questions were left hanging in the air that my 5 and 8 year olds are not ready for!
I really do appreciate your website as a whole, but think that this was a poor choice!
Thanks, Kate, for your helpful comments. I hope that others trying to decide on this book will benefit from your perspective. I know I always appreciate reading different opinions on books before I wade into them. I’m sorry for your disappointment in this title.
This book does include some painful pieces of life — Bo’s abandonment, and later a small boy who is traumatized when he is suddenly orphaned — as well as some women whom we would not choose as role models for our girls. I thought the seeming flippancy regarding Millie was actually Arvid’s attempt to soften the really, really painful blow he knew Bo had been dealt; to not plant more rancour in her bereft heart. Bo’s sense of having lost her mother tracks through the story and I did not see it as a light thing at all. That pain is part of her identity, and I think it actually shapes her quite a bit. My sense was that this loss is a deep part of the story, and that the author was attempting to incorporate it, and let us see how these children were able to move on through the love of others. Your perspective as an adoptive mother is very helpful, so thanks again for that.
Like you, I wondered a bit about including the good time girls in the story, and that is why I specifically mentioned them in my review. But as I kept reading and wrestling with that, I ended up liking how human the author makes these women. You meet more of them further on in the story. As our family has worked closely with many people with very broken lives, addictions, previous felonies, and so on, my kids have learned that they are all complex people, with brokenness, yes, but with tenderness, too. This book seemed to treat these women as I would want to treat them myself and never really says much about what it is they do.
I can understand, though, how this would not suit every family, and as I say, I’m really glad to have your comments for others to reference.
[…] met Dani in an earlier book, My Happy Life, which I reviewed here. She’s a wispy-haired, elfin girl, about age 6 who lives with her dear father. Her mother has […]
[…] in this vibrant Swedish series about Dani. If you haven’t met her before, you really need to begin at the beginning as her wranglings with life as well as her relationships with her widower father, her best friend […]
[…] You are definitely better off reading this series in order. Find my review of the first book in this series, here. […]
[…] via the wonderful people at Gecko Press. You have to read the whole series in order. The first is My Happy Life, reviewed here. For those of you whose daughters have become fast friends with Dani and her BFF Ella, you will not […]
[…] six-book sequence covers about two years of young Dani’s life beginning with My Happy Life, reviewed here. Without giving away too much of the plot, this final episode sees Dani recover from a lengthy […]